9 Devilishly Good Organic Halloween Candies For Fearless Fun
Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links, meaning we get a commission if you decide to make a purchase through the links, at no extra cost to you. We only highlight products we personally believe in!
We’re sharing our favorite organic Halloween candies to help heighten this beautiful fall season.
Spooky season is upon us. Adorable pumpkins are perched on doorsteps to decorate your home. You and your kids are trying to decide the perfect costume for Halloween. We are already drinking our favorite fall-themed drinks like pumpkin spiced boba tea!
The real question is: Trick or Treat? We love our sweet goodies, but the sad truth is that most candy is made with poor ingredients, artificial flavors, and artificial colors. We aren’t interested in skipping caramel chocolate goodies or sour gummies, so we have done a deep dive to unearth organic Halloween candy treats.
Beware, the reviewed candy below is delicious and still has plenty of sugar. We have selected individually wrapped Halloween goodies that would be perfect for a candy bowl in your house, giving out to trick-or-treaters, or as a classroom gift. We have our favorite candies in a bowl at the office.
Healthier Candy Options To Replace The Classics
Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups —–> Justin’s Peanut Butter cups
Snickers —–> Unreal’s Dark Chocolate Caramel Peanut Nougat Bars
M&M’s —–> Justin’s Peanut Butter Jewels
Skittles —–> YumEarth’s Giggles
Hershey Minis —–> Equal Exchange’s Dark Chocolate Minis
Hershey’s Krackel Mini —–> Lake Champlain’s Crispy Milk Chocolate
Mounds —–> Ocho’s Dark Chocolate Coconut Bars
Starbursts —–> Lovely Organic’s Fruity Chews
Sour Patch Kids —–> YumEarth’s Sour Littles
Why Organic Halloween Candy?
Why choose organic Halloween candy? Believe it or not, chocolate can have a dark side—loaded with artificial ingredients, GMOs, and linked to unethical labor practices.
Plus, many conventional candies contain artificial sweeteners, which may have potential health risks, including concerns about cancer, according to research from the National Cancer Institute.
That’s pretty frightening, right? But don’t worry—you can make a sweet difference this Halloween by opting for organic treats made with fair trade chocolate and natural ingredients.
Not only will your trick-or-treaters scream with delight at the deliciousness, but you’ll also be handing out candy that’s been ethically produced and free from harmful additives. These goodies are perfect for the little ghosts and ghouls at your door and for the young at heart adults who appreciate quality and care in every bite.
Our Candy Criteria
We’ve done the tough (and tasty!) job of sampling way too much candy and researching each company, so you don’t have to this Halloween season! Below you’ll find our strict criteria for our organic Halloween candies.
Organic |
Each company listed below uses organic ingredients, ensuring it’s free from GMOs, synthetic pesticides, and harmful additives.
Sustainable |
For our chocolate Halloween treats, each decadent bite is made with fair trade chocolate, supporting ethical labor practices and helping to protect the environment through sustainable farming methods.
Quality Ingredients |
All of the candy companies we selected use high-quality, natural ingredients with no artificial sweeteners, colors, flavors, or preservatives, offering a safer and healthier treat option.
Happy Taste Buds |
Each piece of candy on this list is one we are excited to indulge in and have at the office!
Our Favorite Organic Halloween Treats
Best For | Ordering bulk candy
Ethics | Organic, Non-GMO, free from artificial dyes, and high fructose corn syrup
Price | 50 pieces for $30
YumEarth is on a mission to supply organic treats that are largely allergen-free. All their candy is egg-free, fish-free, gluten-free, dairy-free, peanut-free, selfish-free, soy-free, tree nut-free, and sesame-free. For Halloween, this delightful company has put together variety boxes of individually wrapped treats.
Their popular 50-count Halloween variety box includes:
- the company’s iconic Giggle candy (our favorite Skittle replacement)
- gummy fruits shaped like bats and vampire fangs (who doesn’t love the spooky aesthetic?)
- Lollipops
YumEarth also has a 30-count Halloween variety pack with:
- Chewys (If you love Starburst candies, this is the organic version you have been looking for)
- Giggles
YumEarth’s organic candy is made without artificial dyes and high fructose corn syrup. If you have a hankering for something sour, try YumEarth’s Sour Littlles. These little naturally flavored sour candies are the perfect replacement for Sour Patch kids.
Best For | Organic chocolate goodies
Ethics | Fair-trade certified chocolate, soy-free, non-GMO, natural dyes, and vegan
Price | 12 pack for $34
UnReal is all about reinvention. They’ve taken the classic chocolates we love and reimagined them with real, simple ingredients, cutting down the sugar without losing any sweetness. It’s not just a chocolate makeover; it’s a bold stand against the idea that you have to choose between indulgence and health. UnReal invites everyone to join the delicious revolution and enjoy every bite this Halloween!
We cannot get enough of the dark chocolate peanut gems. The perfect indulgent treat if you are sitting down to a spooky movie, maybe even the new Beetlejuice film? However, we would be remiss if we didn’t mention their coconut and dark chocolate bars. Made with less sugar and no artificial sweeteners, these mounded dark chocolate coconut bars are perfect as a little lunch treat or handing out on Halloween!
Best For | Avoiding common food allergies
Ethics | Vegan, kosher, nut-free, soy-free, and lactose-free
Price | 35 pieces for $35
No Whey Chocolate ensures that Halloween is both fun and safe with their Spook-Free 4-Pack of allergy-friendly vegan treats. With a focus on health and safety, No Whey Chocolate has upgraded their Halloween packaging to stylish, seasonless bags that can be enjoyed year-round.
This variety pack contains individually wrapped cups and minibars that are perfect for Halloween celebrations, school parties, and events, or as a delicious addition to any snack time.
No Whey Chocolate’s treats are free from the top 9 common allergens, including dairy, peanuts, tree nuts, soy, wheat, eggs, sesame, and gluten. They’re also free from artificial colors and flavors, making them an ideal choice for those with dietary restrictions or anyone seeking a healthier alternative.
Each Spook-Free 4-Pack includes:
- Choco No No’s (approx. 6-8 singles)
- Milkless Bars (approx. 8 singles)
- PeaNot Cups (approx. 8 singles)
- Bag of Terror Chocolatey Covered Pretzels (approx. 14 singles per bag)
No Whey Chocolate delivers the perfect combination of safety and sweetness for a worry-free Halloween and beyond!
Best For | Buttercups
Ethics | Dairy Fre,. Non-GMO, certified gluten-free, vegan, kosher pareve
Price | 22 pieces for $30
Craving that rich, creamy milk chocolate taste without the dairy this fall? Free2B’s dairy-free chocolate is crafted with a luscious rice base that perfectly mimics the indulgence of traditional milk chocolate. Plus, they’ve added creamy sunflower butter for an extra touch of sweetness.
The company is spectacularly allergy-friendly. Their products are peanut-free, tree nut-free, dairy-free, egg-free, gluten-free, soy-free, shellfish-free, fish-free, sesame-free, and mustard-free.
Free2B’s individually wrapped cups are perfect treats for tossing into lunchboxes, grabbing on the go, or enjoying anytime you need a chocolate fix this Halloween season. With 22 cups per pack, they’re also great for parties, goodie bags, and sharing with friends.
And it doesn’t stop there—Free2B’s chocolate is ethically sourced, with cocoa coming through the Cocoa Horizon program. When sourced elsewhere, they ensure it’s done responsibly, following the strict OECD Due Diligence Guidance for Responsible Business. So you can indulge with peace of mind!
Best For | Crunchy chocolate treat
Ethics | Certified B Corporation, fair-trade chocolate, organic, non-GMO, no preservatives
Price | 15 pieces for $15.50
Get ready to sink your fangs into some seriously tasty Halloween chocolates! These crispy, crunchy chocolate squares are a wickedly good mix of organic milk chocolate and toasted quinoa puffs, making every bite a delightful treat. If you enjoy the texture of Hershey’s Krackel bars, this organic chocolate goodie is for you!
Lake Champlain Chocolates is a family-owned company situated in Vermont. They began their chocolate-making journey in 1983. Not only do these chocolates taste amazing, but they’re made from high-quality, Fair Trade Certified ingredients, so you can feel great about sharing them with the whole family. Each pack comes with 15 individually wrapped squares, perfect for adding a splash of extra magic to your Halloween festivities.
And if you have a caramel craving, try a bite of Lake Champlain Chocolate’s adorable dark chocolate caramel pumpkins! Creamy caramel wrapped around decadent dark chocolate is the perfect spooky season indulgence.
Best For | Bulk buying
Ethics | Fair-trade certified, organic, vegan, soy-free, gluten-free
Price | 150 pieces for $42
With their silky texture and luxurious taste, these bite-sized chocolates are a delightful way to satisfy your chocolate cravings while supporting ethical farming practices.
Enjoy the deep, rich flavor of dark chocolate minis, crafted with 55% cacao and presented in a convenient display box with a pop-out front. Perfect for setting out during Halloween, or simply savoring from your countertop, these fair-trade chocolates are a delicious treat any time of day.
Vegan, soy-free, and gluten-free, these dark chocolate minis are made using premium organic cacao from small-scale farmers in the Dominican Republic and Peru. The sweetness comes from organic sugar sourced from Paraguay and Costa Rica, and the hint of vanilla is from organic beans grown in Madagascar. By working in cooperatives, these farmers gain essential access to markets, make collective decisions, and invest in their communities.
Best For | An organic peanut butter cup craving
Ethics | Certified organic, non-gmo, sustainable palm oil, BPA-free
Price | 24 pieces for $14
This Halloween, elevate your treat game with Justin’s Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups. Made with the world’s best-tasting organic peanut butter, delicately encased in premium organic chocolate that’s Rainforest Alliance Certified, these cups are pure perfection. Admittedly, we have a peanut butter chocolate addiction here, but we are not overhyping the excellence of this treat!
Justin’s has come a long way from its humble beginnings at a farmers market in Boulder, Colorado, but the commitment to sustainable practices, integrity, and transparency has never wavered. Justin’s sources high-quality, ethically-minded ingredients and partners with organizations to support causes like pollinator conservation and hunger relief, ensuring every product they create contributes to a better world.
And for those who love a little crunch, Justin’s peanut butter jewels are a colorful addition, naturally dyed with fruits and vegetables, with no stevia or sugar alcohols. Treat yourself and your trick-or-treaters to something extraordinary this Halloween—indulge in Justin’s Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups and experience the difference that care and quality can make!
Best For | Healthier Starburst
Ethics | Organic, non-GMO, no artificial colors or flavors, vegan, and gluten-free
Price | 8 oz bag for $10
Lovely Organic’s Sour Fruity Chews are a delightful treat made with care and quality in mind. Crafted in small batches, these chews are not only bursting with Raspberry, Apple, and Cherry flavors, but they’re also organic, vegan, and non-GMO. Individually wrapped for convenience, they’re the perfect sweet (or sour) surprise to share with loved ones. Even if you don’t always check labels, you can trust that these chews deliver taste and values. With Lovely Organic, you’re choosing a treat that’s a winner in every way!
Best For | Organic Snickers craving
Ethics | Fairtrade certified, organic, non-GMO
Price | 12 bars for $38
Ocho’s Fair Trade Certified and USDA Organic chocolate bars are the perfect way to elevate your Halloween treats this year. Made in small batches with handmade fillings, these bars bring an indulgent twist to the spooky season. Whether you’re handing out their rich dark chocolate coconut bars or the decadent chocolate peanut caramel bars, you can’t go wrong.
Founded by natural food expert Denis Ring, Ocho ensures that every bite is free from harmful ingredients:
- No toxic pesticides,
- No GMOs
- No synthetic growth hormones
- No artificial additives.
Treat yourself and your trick-or-treaters to Ocho’s clean, indulgent chocolate for a delicious Halloween!